Username: Password: lost p/w?
home | help | subscribe | search | register
Bend Over Dude, You’re Getting A Dell
Posted by Othertracy! in on July 8, 2008 at 2:29 AM

http://www.mikeshardware.com/reports/dells_happiest_customer/dell_2_lg.jpg

from ripten by Chad Lakkis on July 7, 2008

Manufacturers strive to create innovative products and we as consumers work day and night to afford them. We exit our vehicles and are greeted by the open arms of big box retailers housing shelf after shelf of electronic excess.

We fork over handfuls of hard earned cash for microscopic phones and wafer thin laptops. Each item is priced, each price must be met, and it is instilled in our minds that we get what we pay for … but do we really?

As a blogger you are expected to offer up your opinion and provide your readers with a unique perspective. The more successful outlets do this in a timely and creative fashion on a daily basis. Staying on top means getting every ounce of capability out of everything you have at your disposal … including your hardware.

I bought a Dell laptop months ago with the intention of using it as a command center both at home and on the road. I wanted something powerful enough to run all the image and video editing software that I would need to keep Ripten rocking day and night. I hit the ground running, and everything seemed to be working great, until I decided to record some on-screen video.

Time and time again I tried to record audio and video feeds that displayed on my screen with no luck. I would get the video to record no problem, but the audio just wouldn’t record. I searched for alternative drivers and consulted Dell’s support page to no avail.

Fully frustrated with my semi new purchase, I opened my wallet and switched my focus to software. I began to buy different types of software in the hopes that one would work. I tried Camtasia, Super Screen Recorder, WM Recorder, and a few others I can’t even remember. None remedied the situation. Thoroughly exhausted I gave up for a while, but eventually found myself needing to do it again.

As I began my prep work for this years E3, I thought I would give it one last go before scrapping my laptop (HULK SMASH) and buying a new one. At this point I was convinced that it was a hardware issue, and that the manufacturer of the video card built it with their head up their ass. In what I promised myself would be my final attempt, I searched the web for software yet again.

Being that my problem was audio, I limited my search to “record on screen audio”. The suggested software Google spit back was the ACA Screen Recorder. I installed the trial version, but was met by the same unsuccessful result. The software did however display a link that claimed to address the issue, so I clicked through and discovered that my sound card should have three audio recording options (listed below).

* Microphone/Mic - The audio will be captured from the microphone port
* Line-in/Line In - The audio will be captured from the Line-in port
* Stereo Mix/Mono Mix/WAVE Out - The audio will be captured from the sound card’s speakers port

What? Stereo Mix? Where the fuck is my stereo mix? I only see two options, Mic and Line-in. Perplexed, I refocused my efforts on Google and began to search for the missing third option.

It was not long before I encountered multiple threads started by equally frustrated and confused consumers suffering from the same misfortune. Oddly enough they were all Dell owners with the same SigmaTel brand audio card that I had.

As I dug deeper into the various threads, I soon discovered that the issue had nothing to do with the hardware itself, and everything to do with the restrictions placed on it by the PC manufacturers.

It appears that Dell, and several other computer manufacturers such as Gateway and Pac Bell, were pressured by the RIAA (Record Industry Association of America) into disabling the stereo mix functionality. If true, I find it disturbing that at no time did any of the aforementioned manufacturers see it fit to explain the restrictions they were imposing on our hardware.

One blogger explained that he contacted Dell seeking a solution for his stereo mix woes, and they offered him one — for a $99 fee.

“Since my desktop is new, I decided to contact Dell. After a long online chat and a phone call, Dell told me they had the solution, but if I wanted to know it would cost me $99.00.”

So that we are all clear, the evidence points to Dell appeasing the RIAA by disabling hardware, only to have their customer service reps turn around and offer a solution to their consumers that reverses the alteration they made in the first place at a premium price. I am no rocket scientist, but that sure as fuck sounds fishy to me.

In the end, I was able to restore my laptop’s stereo mix functionality by following a series of registry edits outlined here. While I am now able to record on-screen audio and video, this solution is not something that I recommend everyone attempt, as those who lack the necessary experience to make registry edits could unintentionally cause more harm than good.

The unfortunate reality here is that prebuilt computers are potentially becoming nothing more than an advertising platform for big time brands and a way for highly influential organizations to impose their will on the unaware masses. In the event I decide to make use of a PC again in the future, I will build it with my own two hands.

Update: A Dell Community Ambassador has responded to this post in the comments section below stating that the outbound links in this article are specific to laptops (as was the issue I was having). He has provided a link he claims will rectify the issue, however it is unclear if this will work for all Dell computers that have had the sound card feature disabled by the company.

Also, this does not explain why it was disabled in the first place. If you have a Dell desktop computer with this issue, or the link below simply does not work for your Dell laptop, please let me know in the comment section below or email me at chad@ripten.com.


User Comments

AlternativeDistilled1
Date: July 8, 2008 @ 5:03 AM
my solution was to not run the built in sound card at all, never have ...

my xps came with stereo mix (its a creative xi something or another 2007) it seems to effect the buuilt in the mtherboard cards, and as above with some changes in the registry and or removal of some of the bloat dell/hp/etc put on can be fixed.
but even then for better recording quality even if your going to do some simple screen A/V capture or record a bit of a shoutcast your better off with a under 100usd sound card anyway.


its awful Dell did this and there is no law just the strong arm tactics of the RIAA... people this isn't the first time there are other story's out there JUST like this! stuff to do with the DVD burners as well! we have to keep up the fight and those that work in these industries need to make sure the decision makers know the truth.
Folkvzeye
Date: July 9, 2008 @ 10:42 AM
Pirate
Sound cards which come with computers are usually second rate. It is always better to install your own hi-fi card. I got a great one (Hoontech from South Korea, no longer made) for only $70 an number of years ago and the bass response is very much better than from the factory installed card.
Electronicleedsquietman
Date: July 9, 2008 @ 3:27 PM
Never use onboard audio, especially laptop inbuilt audio, it is high latency piss poor quality stuff. You can get good USB or FW interfaces that give you much better fidelity and quality with non of the hassles for not too much. I have owned 5 Dell computers, they have been quite a good company for me with a fairly good customer service and maintenance. Others have had a different experience. I dont understand if you're running high end video software, why you would cheap out on the onboard audio.

HAving said all of this, the point remains that this option should not be disabled and that is justified.
You must be logged in to post replies to news articles.
Log in or register with the form at the top of the page.

 

 

 

search

news tree


advertising



 

 
© DMusic LLC - Advertising | Employment | TOS | Subscribe