I was just reading an article about it at
the Register. It seems like Merck is trying
to get everyone up in arms scared about
human papilloma virus so they can hawk their
wares, namely Gardasil.
[Code note- see how much Gardasil costs, and how much it helps Merck's bottom line..
"How much will the vaccine cost, and will
insurance pay for it?
The cost of the vaccine is not known at this
time. However, a Merck company
cost-effectiveness analysis assumed a cost
of $300 to $500. Individual or group
insurance plans are subject to state laws.
These laws generally establish coverage
based on recommendations from the ACIP.
Medicaid coverage is in accordance with the
ACIP standard, and immunizations are a
mandatory service under Medicaid for
eligible individuals under age 21. Medicaid
also includes the Vaccines for Children
Program (VFC). This program provides
immunization services for children 18 and
under who are Medicaid eligible, uninsured,
underinsured, and receiving immunizations
through a Federally Qualified Health Center
or Rural Health Clinic, or are Native
American or Alaska Native."] Also, Gardasil
does not protect against all allegedly
carcinogenic forms of HPV.
I believe last time I read the NIH page
about HPV, it said around 92 percent of HPV
outbreaks resolve spontaneously, and that,
in the case of cervical cancer, the
progression from infection with one of the
many strains (there are over a 100 types of
HPV) of HPV virus to cervical cancer is, to
use the NIH's own term, "rare".
http://www.cancer.gov/cancertopics/factsheet/Risk/HPV
Under section 4...last sentence...
"These high-risk types of HPV cause growths
that are usually flat and nearly invisible,
as compared with the warts caused by types
HPV–6 and HPV–11. It is important to note,
however, that the majority of high-risk HPV
infections go away on their own and do not
cause cancer (2). "
I think the HPV answers are clear with
regard to cervical cancer from the material
at the National Institutes of Health...see
the following :
http://www.cancer.gov/cancertopics/factsheet/risk/HPV-vaccine
"What are human papillomaviruses?
Human papillomaviruses (HPV) are a group of
more than 100 viruses. They are called
papillomaviruses because certain types may
cause warts, or papillomas, which are benign
(noncancerous) tumors. The HPVs that cause
the common warts that grow on hands and feet
are different from those that cause growths
in the throat or genital area. Some types of
HPV are associated with certain types of
cancer. These are called “high-risk”
oncogenic or carcinogenic HPVs.
Of the more than 100 types of HPV, over 30
types can be passed from one person to
another through sexual contact. Although
HPVs are usually transmitted sexually,
doctors cannot say for certain when
infection occurred. About 6 million new
genital HPV infections occur each year in
the United States. Most HPV infections occur
without any symptoms and go away without any
treatment over the course of a few years.
However, HPV infection sometimes persists
for many years, with or without causing
detectable cell abnormalities. "
2.Do HPV infections cause cancer?
Infection with certain types of HPV is the
major cause of cervical cancer. Almost all
women will have HPV infections at some
point, but very few will develop cervical
cancer. The immune system of most women will
usually suppress or eliminate HPV. Only HPV
infections that are persistent (do not go
away over many years) can lead to cervical
cancer. In 2006, an estimated 10,000 women
in the United States will be diagnosed with
this type of cancer and nearly 4,000 will
die from it.
[Code note- notice it says, without Gardisil..."The immune system of most women will usually suppress or eliminate HPV."]
Look, studies suggests about 28-29 percent
of women are infected with one or more
strains of HPV. Rarely does an HPV infection
lead to cancer of the cervix. If it were NOT
a rare event, we would have staggering
numbers of women (based on the sampling
indicating almost 1 out of 3 is infected)
dying of cervical cancer.
From 3900-4000 women die from cervical
cancer per year (stats vary according to
reporting site). Contast this with breast
cancer, in 2005, the estimate was about ten
times that, 40,000 would die of breast
cancer.
A little more people than that, men AND
women, die in car wrecks per year, around
43000 Americans are killed in automobile
wrecks every year .
But, all of this PALES relative to the
number of people who die in hospitals per
year. From a report from ABC
http://abclocal.go.com/kgo/story?section=assignment_7&id=4178495
Are Hospitals More Deadly Than Car Wrecks? A
Closer Looks At Hospital Infections
"By Carolyn Johnson
May 16 - KGO - When you go to the hospital,
you probably don't consider the possibility
of becoming more ill after you get there.
But hospital infections are a growing
problem. An estimated 250 people die from
them every day.
People suffering from illnesses or
disabilities severe enough to send them to
the hospital often don't think about the
risk of becoming even more ill while there.
But hospital acquired infections are a
growing problem with serious consequences.
It's estimated 250 people die every day from
infections they picked up in the hospital. "
TWO HUNDRED FIFTY PEOPLE DIE EVERY DAY FROM
NOSOCOMIALLY ACQUIRED INFECIONS (I.E. PICKED
UP FROM BEING IN THE HOSPITAL).
250/day equals 91,250 people just from
hospital infections! This is staggering!
While we are talking about it, there is an
excellent work called DEATH BY MEDICINE,
co-authored by three MDs and a PhD that is a
MUST READ for anyone with an open mind who
is interested in health care issues.
http://www.webdc.com/pdfs/deathbymedicine.pdf
In this very well referenced work (26 pages)
it makes the following statement :
"This fully referenced report shows the
number of people having in-hospital, adverse
reactions to prescribed drugs to be 2.2
million per year. The number of unnecessary
antibiotics prescribed annually for viral
infections is 20 million per year. The
number of unnecessary medical and surgical
procedures performed annually is 7.5 million
per year. The number of people exposed to
unnecessary hospitalization annually is 8.9
million per year.
The most stunning statistic, however, is
that the total number of deaths caused by
conventional medicine is an astounding
783,936 per year."
Almost 800,000 people die every year as a
result of conventional medicine (i.e.
so-called "iatrogenic deaths").
So, these figures really put some
perspective on the HPV scare that Merck, et
al, is trying to foster in hopes of
increasing their profit margin.
Here in Texas, "Governor" Perry, tried to
mandate via executive order, that all young
girls be made to take the KoolAid..er,
"Gardasil". The same day he signed it, he
received a 5000 dollar check from Merck. So
did other legislators. Perry says the check
and his signing of the order, were just
coincidence. It took the Attorney General
of Texas to tell Perry he couldn't make it a
law that all school aged girls had to take
the KoolAid...er, Gardasil.
http://www.belogical.com/
"by Gina Parker Ford
March 14, 2007
What’s that sound? That’s Texas Attorney
General Greg Abbott and the Texas House of
Representatives letting all of the hot air
out of Governor Perry’s unprecedented HPV
mandate!
Following quickly on the heels of General
Abbott’s “informal opinion” on Governor
Perry’s Executive Order mandating girls
entering the sixth grade to get the newly
approved HPV vaccine, the House overwhelming
passed legislation that would overturn it.
After Governor Perry opted to ignore both
our elected representatives and parents’
rights to decide what is best for their
children, Senator Jane Nelson (R-Lewisville)
and Representative Jim Keffer (R-Eastland)
requested that the Attorney General give
them an informal opinion as to the validity
of the Executive Order. According to
Senator Nelson, in the meeting with General
Abbott she learned the order did not carry
the weight of law, or as she put it, “I
guess it’s a friendly suggestion.”
Thankfully, Senator Nelson and other
conservative lawmakers were not so friendly
and successfully passed legislation on
Tuesday that attempts to override Perry’s
executive order. In fact, House Bill 1098
is quite explicit in stating, “Immunization
against human papillomavirus is not required
for a person's admission to any elementary
or secondary school. This subsection
preempts any contrary executive order issued
by the governor.”
But as the bill’s author, Dennis Bonnen
(R-Angleton), pointed out during the floor
debate, "What this bill simply does is say
that we will not mandate the HPV vaccine.
It does not take away the opportunity for
families to decide if this is the right
thing to do for their child."
This is precisely what Governor Perry should
have taken into consideration before issuing
the order, but he instead took the mantra “I
know better than you” to new heights by
completely ignoring parental rights, the
safety and effectiveness of the vaccine, and
the legislature that was already planning to
debate the issue. His authoritarian balloon
has been popped! "