"This would be the classic example of the
straw man argument. Nobody believes the
premise to begin with. "
Auto...you should know you cannot prove that
"Nobody believes the premise to begin
with..."
You cannot prove a negative (e.g. you cannot
prove there are no two headed giraffes in
the world)...
There are people who still believe the earth
is flat, so, I wouldn't put it past some
chuckleheads living in a trailer in Florida
to believe that children are retarded little
animals...in the many child abuse cases
where we have seen kids kept in pens like
animals, one might posit it is possible
these child abusers thought that!
Links on the above...
Flat Earth Society
http://www.flat-earth.org/
and Kids treated like animals
http://facultystaff.vwc.edu/~cbellamy/southern%20literature/SL%20Porter.htm
"Both stories depict children who are
retarded, who are equated to animals by one
or both of the parents, and who are wished
dead or never born (Weisenforth 359).
The title of the story "He" provides the
reader with the first clue that the retarded
son is de-humanized. Throughout the story
the other two of Mrs. Whipple’s children,
Emly and Adna, are given names and are
referred to by their given names. This is
not true of the retarded son. Not once in
the story is He called by his given name. In
fact, the reader never learns his given
name. The failure to give the retarded son a
name is similar to the farm practice of
giving names to pets but not to the
ever-present farm animals. People generally
do not name animals they plan on killing.
Because Emly and Adna have names, they
appear to the reader to be more human. In
contrast, the failure to name the retarded
son makes him appear more animal-like or
less than human.
Another example of animal treatment takes
place during family meals. The retarded son
does not eat his meals at the table with his
family. In a description of the retarded
son, Porter writes "He didn’t whine for
food, as the other children did, but waited
until it was given Him; He ate squatting in
the corner, smacking and mumbling" (597).
When Mrs. Whipple’s brother comes for a
visit, Porter writes "He wouldn’t come into
the dining room, and Mrs. Whipple passed it
off very well" (599). For appearances sake
"Mrs. Whipple loaded up a big plate for Him
first, before everybody"(Porter 599). The
parallels to how people treat their dogs can
not be overlooked. It is common practice for
dog owners to train their dogs not to beg or
whine for food. Many dog owners feed their
dogs in the kitchen, placing their food and
water bowls in the corners. Also, it is
common to feed the dog first so that the dog
doesn’t disrupt the family’s dinner by
begging.
Although it is pitiful that the retarded son
gets treated like an animal, what is even
more sad is Mrs. Whipple’s secret wish for
her son’s death. The neighbors are much more
frank when "talking plainly among
themselves" and felt it would be "A Lord’s
pure mercy if He should die" (Porter 59

."
===========snip===============
AND...
http://www.azcentral.com/specials/special46/articles/0825kidscage25-CP.html
"Parents arrested after twins, 5, caged
'like animals'
Police have to cut boys out
Laura Dobbins
The Arizona Republic
Aug. 25, 2003 12:00 AM
For four months, two 5-year-old Phoenix
brothers lived inside roach-infested cages,
their bodies covered with bedsores.
When police arrived at their home in the
1900 block of North 22nd Street on Saturday
night, the twin boys were wearing soiled
pajamas and officers needed wire cutters to
open their man-made cells.
"They were happy to see us and opened their
arms wide, reaching out to be held and
picked up," recounted Phoenix police Sgt.
Jacqui MacConnell.
Phoenix police officers said their story is
among the most disturbing child abuse cases
they've ever seen.
The boys' parents, Louis and Etelvina
Rodriguez, were arrested on suspicion of two
counts of child abuse and kidnapping. They
are being held at the Madison Street Jail
with bond set at $243,000 each. The children
are in the custody of state Child Protective
Services.
Police discovered the children after the
boys' older brother, 20-year-old Bayron
Grihalua, told officers at a local grocery
store about their living conditions, said
Sgt. Randy Force, a Phoenix police
spokesman. Grihalua could not be reached for
comment Sunday evening.
Etelvina Rodriguez, 42, told police her
husband wanted the boys in cages because he
suffers from health problems and didn't want
to keep up with the active children. Police
did not elaborate on Louis' condition, but
neighbors say the 69-year-old man suffers
from heart trouble."
====================sniP=================
http://www.preda.org/archives/2003/r03062901.html
"Filipino Women and Kids Treated Like
Animals"
"Earlier this year, a group of Swedish Red
Cross students on a social-educational
mission went to the women and child care
center run by the Olongapo City government.
By accident they stumbled upon the secret
jail cells hidden in a back room where
middle-aged women and children as young as
eight are regularly imprisoned, beaten and
deprived of food.
The conditions amount to torture and grave
violations of all civilized humanitarian
rights. An investigation is unlikely – the
center is closed to the press and even
national social welfare officials cannot get
easy access. The mayor's husband is the
Philippine Secretary of Tourism. Officials
deny the reports but the photographs and
credible witnesses are hard to deny. The
police and the municipal social workers
collect the street urchins and women and
incarcerate them behind bars in conditions
not fit for animals."
================SNIP=====================
http://www.thestar.co.za/index.php?fSectionId=128&fArticleId=2463194
"68 kids living 'like animals'
MEC slams living conditions of kids at
illegal Soweto children's home
March 30, 2005
By Moipone Malefane and Poloko Tau
A Gauteng government bid to close down an
illegal children's home in Soweto - a filthy
facility into which 68 orphaned and
abandoned children had been crammed - has
gone badly awry.
Only 30 of the children were last night in
the care of the authorities, while others
had been spirited away by Ethel Mabala or
had taken to their heels.
Soweto police spokesperson Captain Mbazima
Shiburi said the 30 children had been taken
to a place of safety, and officers were
searching for the other 38.
The parents of some of the children had
arrived at the Moroka police station,
demanding to see their children, but that
could only be arranged with the Gauteng
Social Development Department.
For the past 13 years, Mabala ran the
illegal children's shelter from various
addresses in Soweto, in direct contravention
of government regulations and despite
appeals by the authorities to co-operate
with them.
Yesterday she, her husband Michael and son
Benjamin were arrested after she refused to
surrender the children to the Gauteng Social
Development Department.
They were taken into custody after Social
Development MEC Bob Mabaso, who joined
social workers at the home's premises in
Mofolo, told Mabala the children did not
deserve to be treated "like animals"."
============SNIP==================
http://www.americanbible.org/site/PageServer?pagename=secstory_children_treatment&s_newsID=5635
"Some children are treated worse than
animals...
but there is hope for a better life, and you
can help!"
=============snip=============
"The Feral Child – A retard or a survivor –
or both?
GCG
Being feral means subhuman; a feral child is
one whose upbringing consists of a total
isolation from the human species. There have
been the classic cases brought up in
Kipling’s ‘The Jungle book’ represented by
Mowgli and another fictional character is
Tarzan.
But there exist non-fictional cases of these
children…..cases of children being brought
up by dogs in the Ukraine, children brought
up by wolves, children brought up by bears
and sadly children locked up in a room for
most of their lives which constitutes child
abuse.
A child’s mind soaks up like a sponge from
age 2. this age is critical in the childs
upbringing. Altough we dont remember much
from age 2, the function of the cortex part
of the brain is to prepare a foundation for
the following subjects the brain is about to
recieve and store. Mainly the phonetic,
auditory and perception sectors.
Sticking to those children whose upbringing
consisted of animal adoption; these are
humanly retarded however their natural
skills acquired as instinct allow them to
survive in the wild. For example the latest
tsunami incident in SE Asia, we know that
the human death toll soared to a three
hundred thousand body count, however the
animal that succumbed were few in numbers.
This attributed to that extra animal
instinct creatures have to sense events
preemptively."